Two reviews – Julie and Julia/My Life in France

In anticipation of the Julie and Julia movie, I decided to write a joint review of Julie and Julia the book and My Life in France. One I like.  One I didn’t. You can probably guess which one is which.

Here’s what’s so weird – I related more to a dead lady who lived a big chunk of her life abroad than a fellow food blogger who is around my age.   So with Julie and Julia, I just felt like she was moving from one topic to the other without enough context.  It felt like a series of anecdotes but without the context of how life changing and nourishing cooking actually is.   Yes you hate your job as an office drone triaging the needs of 9/11 widows but I’m not getting a sense that cooking Julia’s recipes was anything other than something you did.  Obviously it changed your life but from what I read, BLOGGING about it changed your life more than the cooking.  There were very few points in the book where cooking was pleasurable and nourishing for the soul.  On top of that, things kept on happening to her but I never got a sense of who she was other than some generic 20something trying to figure herself out.

This is in contrast to My Life in France where I felt like Julia and Paul would totally be friends with J and I.  What’s funny is that My Life in France is one of the least food porny books about food there is.  There’s more descriptions of Julia’s frustration with her conservative father than mouth watering descriptions of meals.   Like Julie, food and learning to cook was a life changing event.   What was so satisfying for me about My Life in France was seeing who she was before and after she discovered cooking.  She was an extremely intelligent and socially progressive person who found a stand up guy who shared her values.   I love that she was sharing her and Paul’s frustration wit the crappy politics of the U.S. diplomatic corps and her challenges with co-author Simone Beck.  What encapsulates the book for me isn’t even a written word.  It’s two pages of Valentine’s Day cards she and Paul would send to friends.  They capture the couple that have been so well described in the book.  Pictures of the two of the as an 19th Century couple (with Paul in a toupee), in the bathtub, and sitting on a bench with red hearts pinned to their matching white shirts.  These are two engaged, funny, smart people.

Unlike Julie, I wanted to be part of Julia’s orbit.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Two reviews – Julie and Julia/My Life in France

  1. Scott says:

    MLIF…not MILF…but My Life In France…was very good…a favorite book of mine, period. The adventures she and Paul shared…the love they had for one another…the love they had for food…LOVE!

  2. Bay Area Food Blog says:

    What I loved about MLIF was the WHO of Julia Child. how the marriage worked and the fact that her husband had a job like th rest of us, one that he was good at and paid him decently but that was frustrating with it’s weird office politics. I loved that you saw what led to Mastering. Finding a food community. Taking lessons at Le Cordon Bleu and failing her final because they tested her on housewife recipes as opposed to chef recipes.

  3. Stef says:

    I have to speak up a bit for Julie, though. I don’t know that she did think cooking was nourishing for the soul… I think she enjoyed it, but my take on Julie (who I can relate to a great deal) was that taking on her “project” gave her a purpose and a focus at a time when she felt really adrift in her life. She wasn’t looking for the cooking itself to be the meaning in her life, I don’t think she is that type of person who thinks about what nourishes her soul… instead I think she needed a reason to keep going every day, a routine and a purpose and a goal. She liked Julia Child, she chose cooking. But as I read it, it could’ve been something different entirely and she still would’ve gone through a similar journey of figuring out her life and realizing she was loved. I liked Julie a lot, and I liked her snarky/sarcastic approach even though that’s probably a bit of what has made her feel detached in life. I don’t know that she would even call herself a foodie, even though she’s become famous for this project, because again I think she looked at cooking and food as something different than the cooking and food itself.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s